Plan Commission Could Move on Hospital's Master Plan Draft at May Meeting

Building height is still a sticking point. Chairman wants to see formation of Community Advisory Committee to address numerous specifics of project.


Building height, traffic, buffers, lighting.

The obstacles, which came out of the Lake Forest Plan Commission meeting in March over the proposed master plan to expand the , were still intact after Tuesday night's revisit.

  • See related story:

However, the commission could still vote on a master plan draft at its next meeting May 9.

"It is important, there is momentum and we need to move this project forward," said Cathy Czerniak, Lake Forest Community Development director.

Czerniak took a cue from Plan Commission chairman Jack Reisenberg's closing remarks where he indicated that a master plan could be approved without specifics, such as the building's height.

"There are certain things that we can clearly get agreement to – those go into the master plan – everything else that is part of the consideration for the permit is put into next steps," Reisenberg said. "This is perhaps then supported by a time and event schedule. This is what we have to do, this is the responsibility for it, and this is the timeline, so everyone knows when we are going to address those issues."

"This gives you the opportunity to move forward," Reisenberg said to Northwestern Lake Forest Hospital President Thomas McAfee. "This gives us and all of the other stakeholders the assurance that all of these other things are going to be given the time and attention that they need."

During the nearly four-hour meeting Tuesday night that included more than an hour of public comment, the idea of a community advisory committee to address the specifics of the plan gained momentum.

"The issues that cannot be included in the master plan are then given to this advisory committee," Reisenberg said. "The responsibility of this group, which I view as a subcommittee, deals with these issues, lives to the sequencing of the time and event schedule and comes back to us with a recommendation."

Reisenberg recommended the five-member advisory committee include a representative from Lake Forest Open Lands.

Czerniak said the Plan Commission does not have the authority to create an advisory committee, and the concept would have to be authorized by the Lake Forest City Council.

"So maybe with this first piece we can move forward with your approval based on numerous conditions and sequencing, so we’re clear on how the different details get worked out, how they come back for review as appropriate," she said.

Before the May 9 meeting, Reisenberg asked hospital officials to look again at lowering the height of the proposed new hospital. McAfee said the building height needs to be 96 feet in order to provide a safe and efficient hospital. He cited an outside peer review panel comprised of eight of Modern Healthcare's top 100-ranked health architects which met since the March meeting to review the building plan. Seven supported the proposed height.

However, Reisenberg wasn't comfortable with 96 feet.

"I was probably OK at 81 feet," Reisenberg said. "We've had building height concerns mentioned by other commission members probably 4 or 5 times tonight. It’s an issue that needs some compromise."

Reisenberg said if hospital officials are unable to return with a proposal at 81 feet, then the height condition would not be part of the master plan and would go to the advisory committee for review.

Other issues that could be left out of the master plan and handled through the advisory committee include:

  • traffic proposals for Westmoreland Road at Deerpath, and Waukegan Road and Westmoreland;
  • parking structures
  • lighting

Next Up: An in-depth story from Tuesday night's meeting will be posted Thursday morning.

For more news and updates from Lake Forest-Lake Bluff Patch, “Like” us on Facebook or follow us on Twitter.

Arthur H. Miller April 25, 2012 at 04:31 PM
Several persons have mentioned to me concern about the height of the proposed new hospital structure and its incompatibility with the style and character of the neighborhood. Given some compromising perhaps on absolute height, I have found early 20th c. estate era precedents for treating height with classic and Georgian style to achieve compatibility: 1. This published proposal incorporates two Market Square motifs--the north tower lantern and the west (Marshall Fields) building: http://collections.lakeforest.edu/archive/files/f8e593e454467dbb412d2ad3366150ad.JPG 2. Here's another treatment: http://collections.lakeforest.edu/items/show/4017 3. Here's another classic way to treat verticality, from LF's Alfred Granger (City Hall, College chapel and Reid Hall, etc.): http://collections.lakeforest.edu/items/show/4016 4. This example by Charles Platt (Villa Turicum) would give four or five stories (with basement, etc.): http://collections.lakeforest.edu/items/show/4015 5. Here's another example, this time with Walter Frazier (several LF/LB lakefront houses; book 2009): http://collections.lakeforest.edu/items/show/4019 Hospital planners should be joined by an associated high-level architect experienced in Georgian and classic styles to work with the planners to get both fucntionality/life safety and also compatible architecture: Tom Beeby (Chicago, with local projects), Robert A. M. Stern (New York, recent Winnetka work), etc.
Jim Powers April 25, 2012 at 06:56 PM
Thanks, Art, for these contributions.
Arthur H. Miller April 25, 2012 at 07:23 PM
For the first item, a tall Atlantic City hotel, but with two Market Square like elements on top, I sent readers right to the photo, and missed the captioning. Here is the rest: http://collections.lakeforest.edu/items/show/4018
Lidia Devonshire April 26, 2012 at 12:08 AM
Northwestern can comply with covenant and get its needed parking spots by digging into the ground for a parking structure. This is done all over the world where there is a law, ordinance, covenant to keep structures low. Build down, cut down on light pollution and charge for parking to get it reimbursed over time. Don't break a grantor covenant. Bad precedent and ugly results!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something